Asana vs Trello vs ClickUp for a small team: which fits 3–30 people
For a team of 3–30 people, choose Trello if your work moves through a few visible stages and the team is small enough for its free plan: up to 10 collaborators, and guests and pending invitations count towards that. Choose Asana if your work is made of projects with owners, dates and an order between them, and budget for a paid plan from the third person: Asana’s free plan allows up to 2 seats per project and team. Choose ClickUp if you want tasks, documents and chat in one configurable tool and someone on the team will own the setup; its free plan has no member limit but holds only 60 MB of files. If what the team mostly needs is a record of who promised what in conversation, the list in the chat tool you already use may be enough.
Plans, limits and prices below are what Asana’s, Trello’s and ClickUp’s own pricing and help pages showed when we checked them on 22 November 2026. Prices are US list prices per user per month, as of November 2026. Taxes, regional prices and offers vary, and all three change their plans; open the pages linked here before you buy.
Who each one suits
- Trello is a board of lists and cards: a card moves from one list to the next as work progresses. It suits work with stages, such as orders, applicants or content, where the position of a card is the status.
- Asana is built on projects and tasks. A task has an assignee, a due date and subtasks, and the same tasks can be seen as a list, board or calendar on every plan. Timeline and Gantt views and task dependencies start on the first paid plan. It suits project work that someone has to sequence.
- ClickUp groups tasks with docs, chat, whiteboards, dashboards, sprints and time tracking in one workspace. It suits a team that would rather configure one broad tool than run three, and has someone who will keep that configuration tidy.
Free plans compared
| Asana Personal | Trello Free | ClickUp Free Forever | |
|---|---|---|---|
| People | Up to 2 seats per project and team; accounts on the legacy Personal plan are being moved to that limit | Up to 10 collaborators per Workspace, counting members, guests and pending invitations | Unlimited members and guests; guests have full create and edit permissions |
| How much work | Unlimited tasks and projects | Unlimited cards, up to 10 open boards per Workspace | Unlimited tasks and subtasks, 5 Spaces |
| Views | List, board and calendar | Boards, with unlimited Power-Ups such as the Calendar Power-Up; Trello’s own calendar, timeline, table, dashboard and map views come with Premium | List, board, calendar and table; timeline, Gantt and workload views limited to 60 uses each |
| Files | Unlimited storage, 100 MB per file | Unlimited storage, 10 MB per file | 60 MB of storage in total |
| Automation | Not listed; automations start on Starter | 250 Workspace command runs per month | 100 automation actions per Workspace per month, 5 active rules |
| AI | None listed | Not included; AI starts on Standard | No recurring AI credits listed |
| Chat | Direct messages, team conversations and comments on tasks | Comments on cards | ClickUp Chat: 90 days of history, and 1,000 messages per Workspace in total, a limit that does not reset |
What that means by team size:
- 3 people. Asana’s free plan no longer fits; Trello and ClickUp free plans do.
- 10 people. Trello Free is at its limit with ten members and no guests or open invitations; above the limit, its boards become view-only. ClickUp Free fits on people, but its 60 MB of files and 1,000 Chat messages are shared by the whole Workspace.
- 30 people. Asana and Trello need a paid plan. ClickUp Free Forever still allows 30 members, as long as the team’s use stays within its caps.
What the first paid plan costs and adds
Asana Starter is US$10.99 per user per month billed annually, or US$13.49 billed monthly. It removes the seat limit and adds timeline and Gantt views, dependencies, reporting dashboards, unlimited automations, forms and custom fields. Guests from outside your organization’s email domain are free in an organization; in a workspace without a shared domain, guests count towards the bill. Its included monthly AI allowance is 5 requests per user for AI Teammates and Asana Dash, up to 50 per account. Advanced is US$24.99 per user per month billed annually, or US$30.49 billed monthly, and adds portfolios, goals, resource management and approvals.
Asana sells seats in fixed sizes: 2, 3, 4 and 5 seats, then steps of 5 up to 30. An eight-person team buys 10 seats.
Trello Standard is US$5 per user per month billed annually, or US$6 billed monthly. It adds unlimited boards, AI features, advanced checklists, custom fields, 250 MB per file and 1,000 Workspace command runs a month. Single-board guests are free; Workspace members and multi-board guests are billed. Premium is US$10 per user per month billed annually, or US$12.50 billed monthly. It adds Trello’s own calendar, timeline, table, dashboard and map views, admin and security features, a simple data export, and unlimited command runs, though automation operations still have a monthly quota.
ClickUp Core is US$9 per user per month billed yearly, or US$12 billed monthly. It adds unlimited storage and Spaces, custom fields, unlimited forms and Gantt charts, unlimited ClickUp Chat, 1,000 automation actions a month, email in ClickUp and guest permissions. For AI, it lists a trial of ClickUp Brain² and 1,000 pooled AI credits per user per month. Business is US$17 per user per month billed yearly, or US$25 billed monthly, with more automation, dashboards, timesheets and Google single sign-on. These are ClickUp’s new plans: new Workspaces start on them and some existing Workspaces are being moved gradually, so check your billing page for the plan you are on.
For an eight-person team paying annually at those prices, Trello Standard comes to US$480 a year, ClickUp Core to US$864, Trello Premium to US$960, and Asana Starter, billed for 10 seats, to US$1,318.80.
How tasks get in from a conversation
Most tasks in a small team start as a sentence in a chat or an email. Each tool has its own way to turn that sentence into a task. Whichever you use, confirm the owner and due date after capture.
Asana. The Asana for Slack integration, available on every plan including Personal, turns a Slack message into a task from the message’s menu and keeps a link back to the conversation. Reacting with the 📝 emoji creates a task with the message and its thread replies in the description. Forwarding an email to Asana’s address creates a task in My Tasks: the subject becomes the task name, the body the description, and people in the To and CC fields become collaborators.
Trello. The Trello Inbox is personal and separate from your boards, and the Trello app for Slack can save a Slack message to it. By email, Trello’s shared Inbox address accepts mail only from the address on your Trello account, while your Inbox’s unique address accepts any sender. Each board also has a unique address for each member that creates a card as you. Without AI summary, the subject becomes the card title; emails over 10 MB in total, attachments included, do not create a card.
ClickUp. Inside ClickUp Chat, you can create a task from a message in a channel or direct message, though not from a threaded reply, and choose a List or, where AI is available, let AI choose one. From Slack, a slash command or a message’s menu creates a ClickUp task on any plan; guests and limited members cannot use the integration, and each person connects their own account. By email, a List’s address creates new tasks and a task’s address adds comments, on every plan. ClickUp can also assign tasks with AI when that is set up and AI credits are available.
Turn chat messages into tasks has a checklist for giving each captured task one owner and a date.
What happens to work when someone leaves
Asana. In a paid organization, membership is managed in the admin console. When an admin removes someone from the organization there, Asana offers to create a private project for that person’s tasks and assign it to a member, and after removal it generates a project containing their previously assigned tasks. Removing someone from a division only takes away their paid license: they stay in the organization.
Trello. On a free Workspace, removing a collaborator is two steps: remove them from the Workspace, then from its boards. If they are the only admin of a private board and no Workspace member remains on it, the board is closed instead. On Standard and Premium, deactivating a user keeps their card assignments and frees their seat for reuse.
ClickUp. Removing someone is permanent. Their public items stay, and they still show as assigned to tasks with a Deactivated label until you reassign them; the Bulk Action Toolbar reassigns many tasks at once. Private Folders, Lists and tasks they owned are deleted when they leave, so move anything private into a shared location first.
In every tool, reassign open work before the last day. The handover template lists what to hand over and to whom.
Try one for a week before you decide
Pick one tool and one real workflow, such as client requests or orders, and name one person who owns the trial. At the end of the week, check three things:
- Capture. Every request that came in by chat or email became a task with one owner and a due date, the same day.
- Views. The view the team actually opened each day, list, board or calendar, is included in the plan you would pay for.
- Reassignment. The owner reassigned a test person’s open tasks to someone else, and nothing private was lost.
If one check fails, try the next tool on the same workflow. If all three tools fail on capture, the problem is the handoff, not the tool.
When none of these is the answer
- A small team whose work is said in one chat. A shared list with an owner and a date for each item may be all you need; see a shared to-do list for a small team.
- Ongoing work rather than projects. If most of the week is replies, approvals and small promises, keep a list of commitments and run a short weekly review instead.
Where Opitor fits
Opitor is not a project management tool like these three. It offers direct and group messages, channels, and a Todo List that tracks tasks and deadlines. Calendar shows accessible todo and subtask deadlines; it is not a meeting scheduler. Each person has a personal AI chief of staff in Messages to help with messages, todos, deadlines and drafts. For project views, and for how Opitor can sit alongside each tool, see Opitor vs Asana, Opitor vs Trello and Opitor vs ClickUp, and the FAQ for what is included.
Sources and scope
Vendor pages checked on 22 November 2026; prices are US list prices as of November 2026. These describe documented plans and features, not a hands-on test of each plan.
- Asana: pricing, subscriptions and seats, Personal plan, dependencies, Slack integration, email tasks to Asana, managing organization members and division members.
- Trello: pricing, collaborator limit, Calendar Power-Up, billing, automation quotas, Inbox, saving Slack messages, creating cards by email, removing collaborators from free Workspaces and deactivated users.
- ClickUp: pricing, new plans, view limits, Chat limits, tasks from Chat messages, tasks from Slack, tasks by email, AI assignment and removing someone from a Workspace.